Just One Question | Rev. Jacqui Lewis, PhD: How could God let this happen?

Mallory: For today’s Just One Question, I am bringing a question from Rev. Dr. Jacqui Lewis, who is a senior minister at Middle Church in New York. She’s an author, an activist, a preacher, and a public theologian. Her episode of Insights at the Edge was called What Would Love Have Me Do?

Chris: I love that title.

Mallory: Yes. And just before this clip that I’m about to share, Reverend Lewis is talking about the effects of a fire that happened at Middle Church in 2020. I don’t know if you’re —

Chris: That’s why I know Middle Church. When you said Middle Church, yes, okay, I remember that.

Mallory: Yes. So Tami asks Reverend Lewis something I think a lot of people might ask when looking at a tragedy like this, or just tragedy in general: if there’s a God, how could they let something like this happen?

Chris: Yeah, that comes up so often. I’ve talked with cancer and dying patients for another project, and that always comes up, and the answer is either one of two things: either God is not guiding things at that level, or God is, and we just don’t see the plan.

Mallory: It’s a really interesting question.

Chris: Yeah. Well, let’s see what she has to say. This is Tami Simon asking Rev. Dr. Jacqui Lewis: how could God let this happen?

Mallory: Right after this.

Tami Simon: If members of your Middle Church brought you the question of how could this fire happen to us when God is good — how could this happen to us? This isn’t right. This isn’t fair. Shouldn’t we have been protected from something like this? And this is a very obvious question, and I’m sure it was in the field of your community. How do you address that? Because I think people have this idea — it’s kind of like a childlike idea — that if I’m a deeply faith-filled person, I’ll be immune to certain kinds of tragedies. And yet, obviously, we’re not.

Rev. Jacqui Lewis, PhD: Obviously, we’re not. And that kind of faith leads us to breaking up with God — we’re breaking up with ourselves. There’s a way in which, if the God we are leaning on is nefarious, or fickle, or moody — if God’s gonna punish us if we get something wrong, if the God we create… My field is psychology of religion, and though I believe God is God, we just don’t know enough about God, Tami. So we’re always making up a bit about what this holy one is, and it’s based on our experience, or based on our parenting, or based on the stories we are taught, or the songs we sing.

Stained glass windows — God is made up of lots of our stuff. And if the God we’re relying on is unkind and punitive, and will punish you with a storm called Katrina because people are gay, or will give you a scourge called HIV/AIDS or COVID, or thank God will cause you heartbreak, and that God will make you want to die when you fail that God —

So I was a little person with that God, and I used to write about letting God grow up. There’s no way to have a sustainable relationship with a God who should have protected you from a fire but didn’t — a God who caused the fire to teach you a lesson. That’s a little bit much. That’s a kind of abusive relationship that some of us have with God.

And gosh, if I could wave one magic wand as a clergy, I would say: let that God go. Liberate yourself from that God, and think about instead a kind of vulnerable partner in the universe who wants to be — I’m thinking about Shug Avery telling Celie: God just wants to be loved. It wants you to love the color purple. That’s Alice Walker’s beautiful book. And, yeah, like that we’re in a relationship with this holy one that is not transactional, but is transformative — that is not soothing and [limp — unclear, verify against audio], but a partner. And that comforts me, Tami. I have agency then in my life. And did we start the fire? No, a neighbor’s poor choice started the fire. Did God make the neighbor make a bad choice? No. So my congregation, I don’t think, ever wondered what we did to deserve the fire. We’re walking around the theological constructs that are identity-creating. I mean, there’s a lot — I really believe that our identity is a product of stories told to us, about us, around us.

Stories of gender, stories of sexuality, stories of race, stories of class and caste, and stories of faith, or not faith — an atheist child might not likely hear stories of faith. That child might hear stories of humanism, or what we can do as a people.

And all of those stories get to be refracted, or changed, or synthesized. As we grow up, we interrogate our stories. So if I’m a person who believes God sends a fire, the comforting note I’m writing to the person who had the fire is like: God’s never gonna give you more than you can bear, or thank God you survived it. But, you know, maybe there was a lesson in it, right? And I just, frankly, got very few of those notes, and for that I’m just so grateful. I didn’t get to sit down and have a big theological conversation with those people, but they were like: we love you, and you are our cathedral. Your ministry matters.

We’re praying for you. People who didn’t know us started GoFundMes or Facebook fundraisers. The City of New York just wrapped its arms around us, and from Bendigo, Australia, to Beijing, China, to Paris, to Perry Street in New York — just so much love. How did people even know? So bad news travels, but good news does too.

And the good news that was traveling was that there was a place on the Lower East Side of Manhattan that had been in the same location since 1892. And when the bio says I’m the first Black one since 1628 — our church starts in 1628. We are the ones who bought Manhattan from the Lenape, and we are the ones who built part of the city with the labor of enslaved Africans. So we’re not proud of that. But people saw us trying to love hard, Tami, and they were like: we see you at Stonewall, we see you Black Lives Matter, we see you Women’s March, we see you [Lebanon kids — unclear, verify against audio], and we see you feeding the people.

And they were just so kind. So they held up a mirror to the best part of ourselves. That’s what I’m trying to say. And that’s, I think, a loving thing we can do for each other: I see you. You know, this philosophy of Ubuntu I write about — I see you, and you exist. I see who you are, and I reflect that back to you, and celebrate that, and that helps us become —

Mallory: Listen to the full episode with Rev. Dr. Jacqui Lewis at soundstrue.com, or wherever you listen to podcasts, and we’ll put a link in the show notes. It’s also available on our premium membership platform, Sounds True One. You can learn more about that at join.soundstrue.com. Thanks so much for listening, and we’ll see you next week.

Tami Simon: The Sounds True Podcast Network.